It’s not an easy thing, determining the moment Butch Jones lost his support at Arkansas State. It depends on who you are, I suppose. There were some of us who opposed his hire from the start, heavily influenced by the SEC mob that rode him out of Tennessee on a rail. (Full transparency, I thought it was a good hire, and that his reputation was unfairly maligned by his enemies in the media.) Others couldn’t stomach the two-win and three-win seasons that launched the Butch Jones Era – after all, we had become accustomed bowl games and conference championships. Not everyone has the patience for a rebuild. But there are many moments from which to choose.
It might have begun with that 73-0 blowout to Oklahoma, when an image of a visibly distraught Butch Jones comforted by LB Justin Parks was peppered across the media waves.
Perhaps it was last season, when the Red Wolves dropped two seemingly very winnable games against Southern Miss and Louisiana to fall out of the SBC West race.
It might have been when Arkansas State had, at last, the opportunity to play in-state rival Arkansas, and got throttled 56-14 in Little Rock.
Going 0-4 against Memphis didn’t help, losing on average by 17 points per game.
Going 1-5 against Louisiana didn’t do Butch Jones any favors.
Losing two straight to ULM – after collecting 15 straight from the Warhawks – did not aid the cause of Butch Jones.
Lost in all of this was Jones’ ambitions and accomplishments. Much of it was the kind of work that dirties your fingernails and nobody thanks you for it. When he arrived to Jonesboro in 2021, he was clearly unimpressed by what he saw in the locker room. Too much body fat. Not enough speed. Too little height. Jones made his intentions clear: he would build the program to a higher standard, and he would do so through old fashioned high school recruiting. From 2022 to 2025, Butch Jones recruiting classes would rank 1st, 1st, 2nd and 2nd in the Sun Belt.
However, what happened between 2022 and 2025 was a string of cataclysmic events that transformed college football: NIL, unlimited transfer, expanding playoffs and reckless conference realignment.
Jones was stubborn. In his mind, college football was, like all college courses, a method with which to mold boys into men. He made it personal, recruiting his son Adam, a wide receiver, to the team. Red Wolves fans would see four years of Adam, watching him become a solid player on Butch Jones’ offense. It seemed as though Butch Jones was saying through his son, “This is the way.”
But the direction had changed. Almost overnight, a championship roster was bought, not built. Jones attempted to evolve. In 2022, the program brought in 10 transfers. In 2025, that number ballooned to 33. What fans and Butch Jones would discover together is that the transfer portal was unfairly weighted: the Group of 6 loses its stars and depth, and in return receives malcontents, wash-outs and the occasional gem. For Jones, the process was a mixed result of failure and success.
Still, Jones pushed on. In 2023, Jones led the team to six wins and a spot in the Camellia Bowl, the program’s first bowl appearance since 2019. The team’s sixth win came at home at the the expense of the Texas State Bobcats, in the form of a satisfying 77-31 drumming. The next season, the program registered 8 wins that included a 68 Ventures Bowl victory over Bowling Green. Last year, the Red Wolves upset Appalachian State in Boone to secure its 6th victory of the season, earning Arkansas State a third straight bowl appearance, this time at the first ever XBox Bowl.

Despite the post season appearances, there was discontent among a fan base. Every season, the Sun Belt West was without a dominating program. The division seemed up for grabs. But in Butch Jones’ three winning seasons, the Red Wolves finished second all three times, the most frustrating in 2025, which started with a 1-4 record and would later include flabbergasting losses to Southern Miss and Louisiana that doomed Arkansas State’s campaign to win the division. Both of those latter losses came by one score – a dismaying outcome that had become a trademark to the Butch Jones Era.
It didn’t help that Butch Jones’ chosen style of play was in stark contrast to Blake Anderson’s, who favored a high-powered offense. Anderson’s Red Wolves teams averaged 34.1 points per game. Jones’ offense managed 25.8, a difference of more than 8 points. Butch Jones games were a plodding affair that attempted to control field position and ball possession. Unfortunately, he didn’t have the offensive or defensive horses to drag these games to the finish line. Too many possessions ended in three-and-outs. The defense surrendered too many big plays. A-State fans, infamously fickle to begin with, steadily began to lose interest.
Still, Butch Jones had an opportunity to turn everything around in 2026, his team fresh from an Xbox Bowl win and and his offense led by a new offensive coordinator. As usual, the Sun Belt West seemed open to anyone, and Arkansas State was returning more starters than the majority of the Sun Belt. The window was open.

The season started with a reminder of Butch Jones’ signature failures – a bruising loss to unofficial arch rival Memphis. It was his fourth loss to the Tigers, and the third straight that wasn’t particularly competitive. Jones pointed out that Memphis enjoyed more resources than Arkansas State, which is true, but fans didn’t want to hear it. Losing to Memphis only triggers depression and indignation in Red Wolves fans.
When conference play opened, it marked another loss to Louisiana – Jones’ fifth in six tries. As it was per custom, it was a one-score loss. The next week, the Red Wolves would lose by a single score to South Alabama. A road win over Southern Miss and a homecoming victory over a strong Georgia State team seemed to signal a turnaround. It was a mirage.
On paper, the following matchup against ULM was an almost guaranteed victory. The Warhawks had won but one game all season, and rated near the bottom in all of college football for both offense and defense. Furthermore, the Red Wolves enjoyed a bye week of rest and preparation for a team that had humiliated them last year – ULM broke a 15 year losing streak, an inglorious moment for the Butch Jones Era. Surely the team and the staff were motivated to make an example of the Warhawks before a home crowd desperate to find something, anything to embrace?
The Red Wolves opening drive stalled in Warhawks territory and ended with a missed field goal. After that, things mostly got worse for Arkansas State, with ULM running at will and A-State drives inexplicably stalling against what was supposed to be a weak defense. Still, the Red Wolves held a 14-9 advantage at the half.
In the second half, Arkansas State would score just three points against ULM’s ten, resulting in a 19-17 loss to the Warhawks. Where was the halftime adjustment? Where was the passion? The self respect? A single moment in the second half seemed to sum up the program: the Red Wolves picked up an interception, and a sideline scrum between the two teams ensued. The team seemed fired up! So was the crowd! A quick three and out later, the Warhawks had regained possession. Once again, the Red Wolves had failed to reward a turnover; failed to seize momentum.
Losing once to the Warhawks was bad. Losing twice was an abomination. Once again, the division championship was pulled out of reach due to a one-score game. The program was no longer treading water. After nearly six seasons under Butch Jones, the program was sinking. Next week’s five-turnover, one-score loss to Coastal Carolina underscored the obvious: Arkansas State had reached its ceiling under Butch Jones.
MAIN IMAGE IS MINE
